Wrinkles form on the inside of a bend when the compressed tube wall has nowhere to go. The usual fixes are a correctly set wiper die, a mandrel in the right position, the right pressure die setting and tooling that fits the tube closely.
Why wrinkles form
As the tube is drawn around the bend die, the wall thickens along the inside of the bend and thins along the outside (The Fabricator). When the inside wall is thin or unsupported, the extra material buckles instead of thickening evenly. That buckle is a wrinkle.
Two ratios predict the risk.
- Wall factor is the outside diameter divided by the wall thickness. A 2 inch tube with a 0.049 inch wall has a wall factor of about 41 (The Fabricator). Higher numbers mean thinner walls and more risk.
- D of bend is the centerline radius divided by the outside diameter. Lower numbers mean tighter bends and more risk.
A high wall factor on a low D of bend is the hardest combination. It almost always needs a mandrel and a wiper die.
Causes and fixes
| Cause | What to check | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| No wiper die, or a worn one | Wrinkles start right at the start of the bend | Fit a wiper die and replace it when the tip wears |
| Wiper die set too far back | A gap between the wiper tip and the point where the bend starts | Move the tip up close to tangent, following the tooling maker’s setup |
| Mandrel too far back | Wrinkles or a kink where the bend starts | Advance the mandrel so it supports the tube through the bend |
| Loose tooling fit | Tube can move in the die groove | Tooling sized to the actual tube diameter |
| Too little pressure die force or assist | Tube pulls away from the bend die | Raise pressure gradually, or add pressure die assist |
| Wall too thin for the radius | High wall factor on a tight bend | A larger radius, a heavier wall or a fuller mandrel |
Set tooling in a fixed order
Many operators lean on machine features such as pressure die assist to get adequate parts instead of mastering tooling setup (The Fabricator). Set the tooling first, then tune the machine. The pressure die’s job is only to keep the tube in place, with just enough force to stop it pulling away from the bend die (The Fabricator).
Match the tooling to the tube
Wrinkling is common when the wall is too thin or the tooling is not properly matched to the tube. Match the tooling radius and groove to the tube diameter, and avoid damaged or out-of-round stock.
Lubricate the right places
Use the lubricant your tooling maker recommends on the mandrel and the wiper die. Non-petroleum synthetic lubricants are common between the mandrel and the inside of the tube.
Common questions
Do I always need a mandrel?
No. Thick wall on a generous radius often bends cleanly without one. Thin wall on a tight radius usually needs a mandrel and a wiper die together.
Why do wrinkles appear only on some parts in a batch?
Look for variation in the tube itself, such as wall thickness or diameter changes between lots. Worn tooling and inconsistent lubrication cause the same pattern.
Can more pressure fix wrinkles?
Sometimes, but it can hide a tooling problem and cause new ones such as slipping or wall thinning. Fix tooling position first.
Solve it with ITEC
Send ITEC photos of the wrinkle, the tube size and the radius, and we will help you find the cause. Book an introductory meeting.
