Skip to main content
Solving Bending Problems

How to Stop Ovality and Flattening in Bent Tube

Ovality is a tube going out of round in the bend, and flattening is its extreme form. A correctly sized mandrel in the right position, tooling that fits the tube closely and a radius that suits the wall keep the cross section round.

Why it matters

An oval section reduces flow in fluid lines, weakens the part and can stop it fitting the next component. Ram bending flattens the outside and inside of the bend more than rotary draw does, which reduces flow area. Many pressure and hydraulic applications set a maximum ovality in their specifications.

How to measure ovality

Measure the largest and smallest outside diameter at the middle of the bend. Subtract the smallest from the largest, divide by the nominal diameter and multiply by 100. The result is the ovality as a percentage.

A 2 inch tube that measures 2.06 inches one way and 1.94 inches the other has 6 percent ovality.

Causes and fixes

Cause What to check Fix
No mandrel on a thin wall or tight radius Wall factor and D of bend Add a mandrel, with balls if the bend needs support through the arc
Mandrel set too far back Flattening at the start of the bend Advance the mandrel toward the bend
Mandrel too small for the tube Clearance between mandrel and tube wall A mandrel sized to the actual inside diameter
Die groove too large Tube can spread sideways in the groove Tooling made for the actual tube diameter
Out-of-round or damaged stock Measure the tube before bending Reject damaged stock and check incoming material
Radius too tight for the wall A low D of bend on a thin wall A larger radius or a heavier wall

How mandrel choice affects roundness

  • A plug mandrel supports the tube up to the start of the bend. It suits heavier walls and moderate radii.
  • A ball mandrel adds linked balls that follow the tube into the bend. It supports thinner walls and tighter radii through the arc.
  • More balls give more support but add drag, which can increase wall thinning. Use as many as the bend needs and no more.
AMOB CH 220 bending 8.625 inch tube with a 0.078 inch wall at 2D. Large diameter with a thin wall is the hardest case for roundness, so the mandrel and tooling are matched to the tube.

Common questions

What ovality is acceptable?

It depends on the application. Check your part specification or your customer’s standard. Agree on the limit before tooling is ordered, since it drives mandrel choice.

Can a mandrel cause problems?

Yes. A mandrel set too far forward can bulge or mark the tube, and too much drag thins the wall. Position it according to the tooling maker’s setup and test on real parts.

Does ovality get worse as tooling wears?

It can. Worn grooves and worn mandrel balls let the tube move. Inspect tooling on a schedule and keep spares for high-wear parts.

Solve it with ITEC

Send ITEC your tube details and your ovality limit. We will help you choose the mandrel and tooling setup that keeps parts round. Book an introductory meeting.

The World’s Largest Range of
Tube, Pipe & Profile Bending Machines